No longer a Cinderella line backwaterFor many years prior to Transport for London taking over the line in November 2007 as part of the new London Overground, the Gospel Oak-Barking line (GOBLIN) was one of London’s forgotten railways, neglected and unreliable. Its trains were among the oldest on the network and were often lightly used as a consequence. Its unstaffed stations also made it a route to be avoided, given a choice. Almost perversely, despite those deterrents, ridership in the latter days of Silverlink Metro continued to rise and some additional services, using the class 150 DMUs, were introduced.
The past decade with London Overground operation has seen major investment and resulting changes, including new class 172 2-car Turbostar trains with better reliability and improved frequencies following resignalling, and improved staffed stations. This has led to a very significant further upturn in passenger numbers, such that Arriva Rail London Ltd, like their predecessor London Overground Rail Operations Ltd (LOROL), are using every available diesel train they have to the maximum possible extent ahead of platform lengthening for new 4-car trains and electrification of the line. The extra route capacity from resignalling has also meant that more freight trains are being routed over the line.
The line has increasingly become a victim of its own success. Services are operated at 15-minute intervals by two-coach diesel multiple units. The inexorable growth in passenger numbers means that during peak periods trains are heavily overloaded, with passengers often being left on the platform. ARL run some extra 'PIXC-buster' trains using their maintenance spare stock, but otherwise capacity is constrained; there are no spare paths to run extra trains, no suitable rolling stock available to lengthen the diesel trains, and platforms at some stations (particularly South Tottenham) have until recently been too short to accommodate longer trains. This will be finally resolved when the line is electrified and 4-coach electric trains are available in early-2018.
- Funding for electrification of the line was announced by the government on 27 June 2013 in Investing in Britain's future, for a start of works in 2016 and completion in 2017.
- TfL announced its search for a supplier of new 4-car electric trains in April 2014, and published a short-list of bidders in July 2014.
- TfL then confirmed an order in June 2015 for new electric trains.
- In late-September 2015 it was reported that a local contractor had been awarded the civil engineering work required to electrify the line, ending anxious months of speculation about when the work would proceed.
- In February 2016 Network Rail announced that there would be a partial closure, east of South Tottenham, from June to September 2016, followed by full closure from October 2016 to February 2017, for the electrification work to be completed.
- On 6 April 2016 public information drop-in sessions between mid-April and early-May at stations along the line were duly announced by Network Rail and by TfL.
- Just a week later TfL confirmed the new operator to be Arriva Rail London, to take over from LOROL in November 2016, and be responsible for introducing the fleet of new 4-car electric trains from 2018. This followed a competitive bidding process begun in April 2015, announcement of the short-list of bidders in June 2015, and TfL's announcement of Arriva Rail London Ltd as its preferred bidder in March 2016.
- A month later TfL reminded passengers that the first line closure would start from Saturday 4 June, until February 2017; however weekday-only services would continue to run between Gospel Oak and South Tottenham until Friday 23 September 2016.
- On 1 September TfL reminded passengers that the next phase of works with the full line closure was just three weeks away, and then reinforced the message with just one week to go.
- In early-February 2017 came the good news from Network Rail that the line was about to re-open, but also the bad news that the works were not complete, necessitating further line closures.
- Then on 26 July came confirmation from Network Rail that the works would be be completed in time for the arrival of the new, longer electric trains in early-2018, although some further weekend and extended full line closures would be needed to meet that target.
- On 17 October the 2017/18 winter closure dates were confirmed: from 18.30 on Saturday 18 November until Sunday 14 January inclusive.
Gospel Oak-Barking line will be extendedThe Barking Riverside Extension will take GOBLIN services further east to support a new 10,800-home development. On 4 August 2017 the Secretary of State for Transport approved TfL's application for a Transport & Works Act Order and deemed planning permission to construct and operate the extended line to Barking Riverside. On 8 August the Mayor of London and TfL welcomed the news, as it marked the conclusion of a three-year process of consultations, and followed a Public Inquiry in October 2016 to which a letter of support from Railfuture for TfL's application had been submitted.
The process began formally with a September/October 2014 public consultation, which was reported to command overwhelming support in January 2015. Further public consultation then took place in May/June 2015 on alternative route alignments. The Mayor of London then asked TfL to seek powers for construction in March 2016, and in May/June a statutory consultation took place on TfL's application to the Transport Secretary for a Transport and Works Acts Order. In August 2016 TfL began to procure a contractor, which was followed by the short-list announcement in December 2016.
Gospel Oak-Barking line will be electrifiedThis short briefing restates the case for electrifying this crucial missing link.
The Gospel Oak to Barking Line (GOBLIN) is a 21st century anomaly among London’s railways. It is a 12 mile non-electrified rail route linked to electrified lines at each end, and with other key routes in between. Along the route it links to four more electrified lines: the Thameslink/Midland main line, the East Coast main line, the Lea Valley line (between Stratford and Tottenham Hale) and the Enfield Town and Southbury Loop lines via Seven Sisters.
Since the line is not electrified, it can only be operated by diesel trains; electric trains (whether passenger or freight) from other routes cannot use it. Electric-hauled freight has to use the North London Line, and pass through very busy junctions at Camden Road and, more importantly, Stratford and Forest Gate, where freight trains can delay passenger services.
Benefits for passengers and train operationsElectric trains have better acceleration and an Overground fleet of 4-car electric trains would be able to carry many more passengers, relieving overcrowding. All-electric extensions of the service at each end of the route, which TfL wants to run, become possible, such as to Barking Riverside in the east and/or to Willesden Junction/Clapham Junction (even Ealing?) to the west. Some other works would be needed, such as new platforms and subways at Gospel Oak on the through lines there.
Freight strategy benefitsThirty container trains a day are expected eventually from London Gateway/Thameshaven, on the Essex Thameside route, which is currently being expanded. Most will go to the West Coast main line but without electrification of the Barking-Gospel Oak line electrically-hauled freight trains will add further pressure on the Great Eastern main line and the North London Line.
Electrification adds operating flexibilityElectrifying Gospel Oak-Barking and its connections will give rail operators greater flexibility for maintaining services during disruptions and engineering work. It will also provide an important alternative route for electric container trains from Tilbury, and any traffic that comes from the Channel Tunnel high-speed line at Ripple Lane Barking.
Electric passenger and freight services between Stratford and Gospel Oak could be diverted through Temple Mills and South Tottenham, away from the North London Line. During weekend engineering works, or even during an extended blockade of the Camden Road to Stratford section, some North London Line trains could also operate this way to Stratford.
Links to two other electrified lines were also due to be electrified. These are to Carlton Road Junction on the Thameslink/Midland main line, and the Harringay Park curve to Ferme Park providing a vital link to the East Coast main line.
A better greener image - improving the environmentElectric trains are cleaner and quieter than diesels, and will fit in with TfL’s aim of promoting the Overground as a fast and modern equivalent of the Underground. This in turn will boost the image of the service and areas served by the line, thus assisting regeneration.
Cutting emissions and pollutantsElectrification will play rail's part in reducing oxides of nitrogen, one of the worst by-products of diesel propulsion.
Commitment to electrification at lastTransport for London, the Rail Freight Group, the line’s passengers, and informed rail experts were all convinced of the unanswerable case for an electrified GOBLIN.
In the Chancellor of the Exchequer's Autumn Statement on 5 December 2012 the scheme lost out again. On 20 December Jeremy Corbyn MP received the following written answer, to this question: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what recent (a) information, (b) advice and (c) reports he has received on the case for electrification of the Barking to Gospel Oak section of the North London Line; and if he will make a statement (134793). Mr Simon Burns: Although there is no new funding available, the Department is working with Transport for London and Network Rail to review the case for electrification. A detailed breakdown of the £90 million cost of electrification has been provided by Network Rail. Transport for London has provided its business case for using longer electric passenger trains and has offered £25 million towards the cost of electrification.
Network Rail's Strategic Business Plan for their Control Period 5 from 2014-19, published in early-January 2013, was the next official word on the subject. The ORR ran a public consultation on the SBP until 19 February. The next step was publication on 12 June of their Draft Determination on that Plan, accompanied by the start of a consultation until 4 September. Then the ORR's Final Determination was issued on 31 October 2013. Finally, just before the start of Control Period 5 on 1 April 2014, Network Rail published their five-year Delivery Plan for 1 April 2014 to 31 March 2019. Full details on the ORR website here.
Then, at long last, a day after the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced the Comprehensive Spending Review for public spending in 2015/16, Chief Secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander published Investing in Britain's future on 27 June 2013 and there in para. 3.21 is the good news!
Electrification of Gospel Oak-Barking is now embedded in Network Rail's Enhancements Delivery Plan for CP5. See 'England and Wales Projects: Anglia' in which "infrastructure ready for use" is given as June 2017.
Railfuture has continued to champion the cause of an all-electric GOBLIN!
You can write to the four Members of the Greater London Assembly along the line - for Barnet & Camden, Enfield & Haringey, North East, and City and East: GOBLIN Assembly Members.
or the nine MPs along the line: see a map of GOBLIN constituencies (names subject to change!) and contact GOBLIN MPs.